Halloween Pre-Order

Halloween is my favorite holiday to decorate cookies for. So I put together a large collection of options, from decorated cookies, to creepy eyeball cookies, to a drop cookie box that will satisfy all of your ghouls and goblins. Don't forget to order the ever popular DIY kit for a fun activity to do if you're planning on staying home this Halloween. And lastly, if the ghost in your life happens to be gluten free, I made several options for them as well.

This year's Halloween pre-order was going so well I had to turn off the decorated cookies within 17 hours of launching. All those who were on the newsletter list gobbled them all up. Be sure to get your name on the newsletter list (at the bottom of the page), and make sure mailonebakersjourney@gmail.com is listed as an approved email address so you don't miss out.

Personalized Trick or Treat Pail

A single cookie that measures approximately 3.75" tall and customizable with a name. Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Pumpkin Ghost

A single cookie that measures approximately 3.75". Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Poison Apple

A single cookie that measures approximately 3.75" tall. The black icing will even turn the eater's mouth black for added effect. Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Zombie Head with Worms

A single cookie that measures approximately 3.5" wide and includes two gummy worms. Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Halloween Mini Pack

This mini set has four cookies each measuring about 2". Each set is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Monster Mash Mini Pack

This mini set has four cookies each measuring about 2". Each set is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Witch’s Brew Mini Pack

This mini set has four cookies each measuring about 2". Each set is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Murder Weapons Mini Pack

This mini set has four cookies each measuring about 2". Each set is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Halloween Cookie Pop

A single sugar cookie on a stick that measures approximately 4" tall. Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow.

Halloween DIY Cookie Kit

This DIY kit will come with 6 or 12 cookies consisting of three designs, a ghost, a pumpkin, and a bat. Each cookie measures about 4" and comes with 4 colors of royal icing. This is the same icing that I use to decorate all the cookies you see above. The set comes with instructions and a couple of toothpicks, but all you need to do is snip the tips of the icing bags and have some fun. For littles that find the bags too hard to handle, icing can also be applied with a butter knife or spoon.

Rice Crispy Treats

Order includes one treat, either plain or decorated with white chocolate and sprinkles. Whichever you choose, you can't choose wrong. My brown butter rice crispy treats take the rice crispy treats you grew up with to the next level. Each treat is individually sealed and tied with a bow.

Creepy Eyeball Chocolate Chip Cookie - $4

A single chocolate chip cookie with a gummy eyeball and royal icing eyelid. The eyeball color will be random. Also available as gluten free. Each cookie is sealed in a bag and tied with a bow

Drop Cookie Box - 24/$18 GF Birthday Cake and Chocolate Chip

Each drop cookie box comes with 24 cookies. Choose from Gluten Free Birthday Cake, Chocolate chip, or Gluten Free Chocolate Chip. Each box can be one or two flavors of your choosing.